Pick a brand that names its leather. Full-grain leather wears in well. Read the...

https://zulu-wiki.win/index.php/How_Do_I_Avoid_Drop-Shipped_Leather_Wallets_That_Peel%3F

Pick a brand that names its leather. Full-grain leather wears in well. Read the warranty to see what it covers and for how long. Check how initials go on, too. A stamp, foil, or tag can affect the look and wear of a gift over time.